Job Site Reviews
All of the career sites I describe below are completely free for job seekers. They make their money from advertising,
from fees employers pay to post job openings and search for your resume, and from additional services that many offer
to you.
These additional services often include help writing your resume and emailing, faxing, or mailing your resume to many potential employers. I have never used any of these services. My personal opinion is that it is less expensive to buy a good book on how to create a good resume, and that employers are probably not interested in being spammed with unsolicited resumes no matter what method of delivery is used.
The key differences between sites are:
These additional services often include help writing your resume and emailing, faxing, or mailing your resume to many potential employers. I have never used any of these services. My personal opinion is that it is less expensive to buy a good book on how to create a good resume, and that employers are probably not interested in being spammed with unsolicited resumes no matter what method of delivery is used.
The key differences between sites are:
- The types and quantities of jobs listed
- The number of different targeted resumes you can store
- How many of your resumes are searchable by employers
- The formatting of your resumes on the site
- The job search options
- The automatic notification options (job search agents for email or RSS)
BestJobs USA |
| Jobs: General career site. I did a search with no filtering and only found 7,713 jobs
(on 11/30/2005). Resume Quantity: One. Searchable Resumes: One. Resume Formatting: Text only. Search Features: Searches can be filtered by state and city (picked from a list). You can select a category from a list, and enter keywords that can only be treated as "all". Recommendations for you: You can probably safely overlook this one. Recommendations for them: Get serious or shut down. |
Career.com |
| Jobs: Submitting the registration form on this site results in a "Page not found"
error. A search for all types of jobs in all states in all categories resulted in only 400 or so matches.
I randomly looked at several job postings and each one was from 2003. It seems safe to assume that this site
is dead, but no one has had the decency to bury it. Recommendations for you: You can safely overlook this one. Recommendations for them: Sell the domain name to someone that will actually use it. |
CareerBoard.com |
| Jobs: A general site supporting only nine metropolitan areas. Resume Quantity: Three. Searchable Resumes: All three, which is great if you are targeting different types of jobs. You may pick up to three categories and enter up to 500 characters for a description of your desired job. Resume Formatting: Text only. Officially. Unofficially, HTML works. No documented size limit. I was able to paste in all 59k of mine without a problem. For HTML, you can only use plain HTML (no CSS), you must only paste what is between the "BODY" tags, and you need to make the whole file into one long line to avoid having extra vertical space that you don't want. They do not provide any of these instructions on their site – I had to figure them out the hard way. Cover Letters: Five. Applications: Supported. Search Features: Searches are for one metropolitan area only and can be filtered by selecting a category from a list, and enter keywords for "any", "all", and "exact phrase matching". Agents: Several, based on searches. Email alerts can be text or HTML. Email frequency is daily only. Recommendations for you: A good place to post your resume if you are looking within the areas that they cover. For searches and alerts, you are better off using SimplyHired which includes the jobs from this site. Recommendations for them: Fully support HTML resumes, including CSS. Support many more characters for keywords in searches (750 would be nice) along with a full set of Boolean operators (or at least add a box for "not" entries). |
Career Magazine |
| Jobs: The software used by this site is the same as that used by
Beyond.com (4Jobs.com). See that review (above).
In fact, they seem to use the same resume and job databases and this may simply be another "brand name" for
the same company. The main differences seem to be the color scheme, the top banner, and the copyright notice. Recommendations for you: Use this or Beyond.com (4Jobs.com), but not both. Recommendations for them: Just redirect users to Beyond.com (4Jobs.com). |
Career Shop |
| Jobs: This site had less than 450 jobs in all categories in all locations with no
keywords specified when I checked on 12/3/05. Search Features: Few. Recommendations for you: You can safely overlook this one. Recommendations for them: Sell the domain name to someone that will actually use it. |
CareerJournal |
| Jobs: Run by The Wall Street Journal's CareerJournal,
this site uses the careercast.com platform, but all such sites have their own unique job databases. Resume Quantity: Several. Searchable Resumes: All, which is great if you are targeting different types of jobs. Each resume is part of a profile, which includes up to five job categories picked from their list, and a text box to enter locations to which you would consider relocating. Resume Formatting: Text and HTML (including inline style attributes) are supported and you can upload Word and Acrobat files. There is no documented maximum size. Cover Letters: More than five text or text cover letters with no documented maximum size. Applications: Supported, using your choice of resume and cover letter. Search Features: Supports "all", "any", and "not" (use a "-" before a word) keyword matching with over 500 characters allowed for the search string. You may pick only one category from their list. You can also enter one zip code or one state and choose a radius centered on that location. Agents: You can save multiple search agents that use all of the search features. Results can be emailed to you as text or HTML with several choices for frequency. The emails list the title, company, city, and state of the first ten job matches with links to the full postings and the rest of the search results. When you click in the email to see the full set of results, it does not remember the number of jobs per page or the time span of the search. Recommendations for you: A good place to post your resume if you are looking within the Columbus, Ohio metropolitan area. For searches and alerts, this site is very good. Recommendations for them: Add at least a little bit of the job description and the salary (if available) for each job to the agent emails to avoid having to examine each agent result in detail. Have the link in the email for the full search results remember the number of jobs per page and the time span of the search. |
Careers on InfoWorld |
| Jobs: It has links to ITcareers.com for actual
job hunting and resume posting. Additional Features: This site seems to offer good resources for job seekers in the IT field such as salary and state job outlook information, but all of it is quite old. I didn't see anything newer than 1999. Recommendations for you: You can safely overlook this one. Recommendations for them: Update the data or take down the pages. |
ColumbusJobs.com |
| Jobs: Contains the job listings from the classifieds section of The Columbus Dispatch,
our local daily paper. It uses the careercast.com platform, but all such sites have their own unique job databases. Resume Quantity: Several. Searchable Resumes: All, which is great if you are targeting different types of jobs. Each resume is part of a profile, which includes up to five job categories picked from their list, and a text box to enter locations to which you would consider relocating. Resume Formatting: Text and HTML (including inline style attributes) are supported and you can upload Word and Acrobat files. There is no documented maximum size. Cover Letters: More than five text or text cover letters with no documented maximum size. Applications: Supported, using your choice of resume and cover letter. Search Features: Supports "all", "any", and "not" (use a "-" before a word) keyword matching with over 500 characters allowed for the search string. You may pick only one category from their list. You can also enter one zip code or one state and choose a radius centered on that location. Unlike other careercast sites, there is no option to pick job types: direct, contract, or both. You can choose whether or not to include jobs from the national database (this includes ads from papers across the country). Agents: You can save multiple search agents that use all of the search features. Results can be emailed to you as text or HTML with several choices for frequency. The emails list the title, company, city, and state of the first ten job matches with links to the full postings and the rest of the search results. When you click in the email to see the full set of results, it does not remember the number of jobs per page or the time span of the search. Recommendations for you: A good place to post your resume if you are looking within the Columbus, Ohio metropolitan area. For searches and alerts, this site is very good. Recommendations for them: Allow selection of multiple categories in one search. Add at least a little bit of the job description and the salary (if available) for each job to the agent emails to avoid having to examine each agent result in detail. Have the link in the email for the full search results remember the number of jobs per page and the time span of the search. |
ComputerWork.com |
| Jobs: Over 5,500 High Tech jobs. Resume Quantity: One. Searchable Resumes: One. Resume Formatting: Text only. They specifically state that you should not use HTML, however most HTML seems to work. For HTML, you can only use plain HTML (no CSS), you must only paste what is between the "BODY" tags, and you need to make the whole file into one long line to avoid having extra vertical space that you don't want. "CENTER" tags and "ALIGN=center" attributes are ignored, but heading tags seem to be centered whether you like it or not. They do not provide any these instructions on their site – I had to figure them out the hard way. Search Features: Searches can include only nine keywords, which are joined by your choice of "or" or "and". The only other filtering offered is by state, metropolitan area, or area code and by job type (full time, etc.). Agents: The email from the agent only provides a link to the site, where you must go to see the new positions. Each is placed in a personalized section of the site, and you need to manually delete each one individually one wait six days for them to be automatically removed from your list. Recommendations for you: A good place to post your resume, but I recommend using Indeed.com to find listings from this site. SimplyHired does not yet include this site's database as of 12/5/05. Recommendations for them: Fully support HTML resumes, including CSS. Allow multiple searchable resumes. Totally overhaul the user interface for keyword matching to support full Boolean expressions. Get more job listings. |
|
| Jobs: Over 81,000 jobs for technology professionals. Resume Quantity: Several. Searchable Resumes: One. Resume Formatting: Text, HTML, or a link to a web page. Search Features: Support all Boolean operators and parenthesis, however they only allow a 120 character string. Filtering by state or area code is supported, but not filtering by category. Agents: You can save up to five search agents. The matches are emailed to you as your choice of text or HTML and with your choice of daily or weekly frequency. Recommendations for you: A good place to post your resume, as it has some great job listings that I didn't find anywhere else. For searches and alerts, you are better off using SimplyHired which includes the jobs from this site. Recommendations for them: Add an option for each resume to make it searchable or not. Support much longer keyword strings (750 characters at a minimum). |
Employment 911 |
| This site has very, very few jobs and seems to exist mainly to sell their Resume Writing and "Resume Blasting" service. In my opinion, this one is a waste of time. |
| Jobs: Indeed is a search engine for jobs. In
one search, you get free access to millions of employment opportunities from thousands of websites. They include
the job listings from over 1,000 major job boards, newspapers, associations and company career pages. They
do not publish a list of their sources, so you have to figure out on your own which individual job board agents
you can get rid of once you set up an alert here. Indeed has a de-duplication system that collapses multiple
jobs under one result. Where this occurs, duplicate jobs can be viewed by clicking on a link beneath the result. Resume Quantity: None. Search Features: Searches support "AND", "OR", "-" (for "NOT"), and parenthesis but only allow about 250 characters for the entire string. You can also filter by a city, state, or zip code. In advanced search, you can also enter keywords for "at least one", "all", "exact phrase", "none", "title", or "company" filter by the age of the posting, and choose a radius from your chosen location. Since every job board categorizes jobs differently, there is no option to filter jobs that way. Therefore you may want to think twice about using this instead of the individual job board agents, depending on your particular needs. Agents: Searches can be saved as email alerts or as an RSS feed. Emails are sent daily in HTML format and contain the title, company, city, state, originating job board name, posting date and time, and the first bit of the description for the first 20 positions and a link to the full set of matches. Recommendations for you: An excellent search engine covering many job sites. You should consider using this instead of a site's own agents if you see results from that site in the Indeed results. That cuts down on the number of emails you'll get, and much of the duplication of jobs between sites. Recommendations for them: Allow for at least 750 characters in the search string. Publish a list of the sources being searched or allow a search for whether a particular site is included. |
Internet Job Source |
| Very few job listings, but a great source of links to state and city specific job sites. |
IT Careers |
| Jobs: This is a partnership of The Wall Street Journal's
CareerJournal and ComputerWorld.
It uses the careercast.com platform, but all such sites have their own unique job databases. Resume Quantity: Several. Searchable Resumes: All, which is great if you are targeting different types of jobs. Each resume is part of a profile, which includes up to five job categories picked from their list, and a text box to enter locations to which you would consider relocating. Resume Formatting: Text and HTML (including inline style attributes) are supported and you can upload Word and Acrobat files. There is no documented maximum size. Cover Letters: More than five text or text cover letters with no documented maximum size. Applications: Supported, using your choice of resume and cover letter. Search Features: Supports "all", "any", and "not" (use a "-" before a word) keyword matching with over 500 characters allowed for the search string. Unlike the other CareerCast sites, this one does not provide filtering by job category. You can also enter one zip code or one state and choose a radius centered on that location. Agents: You can save multiple search agents that use all of the search features. Results can be emailed to you as text or HTML with several choices for frequency. The emails list the title, company, city, and state of the first ten job matches with links to the full postings and the rest of the search results. When you click in the email to see the full set of results, it does not remember the number of jobs per page or the time span of the search. Recommendations for you: A good place to post your resume and for searches and alerts. Recommendations for them: Add filtering searches by job category. Add at least a little bit of the job description and the salary (if available) for each job to the agent emails to avoid having to examine each agent result in detail. Have the link in the email for the full search results remember the number of jobs per page and the time span of the search. |
ITClassifieds.com |
| Jobs: A division of CareerEngine.com, this is a
career site for IT professionals, with 621 jobs listed as of 12/6/05. A test
search for "Oracle" anywhere in the US only returned 91 jobs. They claim 100,000 unique visitors per month,
but I can't imagine why so many people would bother with this site. I wonder how many visit more than once
or twice. CareerEngine.com has other sites specifically for Accounting,
Engineering, Financial, and Sales. All have the same poor software and relatively few job listings. Resume Quantity: Five. Searchable Resumes: One. Resume Formatting: Text only. Cover Letters: None. Search Features: Searches provide one keywords box with your choice of "any", "all", and "exact phrase" modes. You can filter on up to five states or area codes and there are checkboxes for "full time", "part time", and "consulting". Agents: You can have more than nine agents. They have a different set of search criteria than regular searches. For agents there is simply a keywords box with no clue as to whether they are combined using "any" or "all". You can filter on just one state or area code, and there are no checkboxes for job type. You can optionally paste in a different resume for each agent and have that resume sent automatically in response to any job that agent discovers. Given the poor search features, I think that is a very bad idea. Recommendations for you: With so few jobs and such poor search agents, I'd skip this one in favor of better IT job sites listed on this page. Recommendations for them: Look at the features offered by your competitors and then decide if you want to improve or just find another line of work. |
Job-Hunt.org |
| A job search guide and resource directory with links to many useful job sites that are for specific states or industries. |
JobWeb.com |
| A good selection of articles, all geared to new graduates. No job search. |
| Jobs: Lee Hecht Harrison is a major outplacement
firm and part of the Adecco family of companies, so they have a huge
number of listings. It uses the careercast.com platform, but all such sites have their own unique job databases.
I have gotten more calls from recruiters who say they found my resume here than from any other site. Resume Quantity: Several. Searchable Resumes: All, which is great if you are targeting different types of jobs. Each resume is part of a profile, which includes up to five job categories picked from their list, and a text box to enter locations to which you would consider relocating. Resume Formatting: Text and HTML (including inline style attributes) are supported and you can upload Word and Acrobat files. There is no documented maximum size. Cover Letters: More than five text or text cover letters with no documented maximum size. Applications: Supported, using your choice of resume and cover letter. Search Features: Supports "all", "any", and "not" (use a "-" before a word) keyword matching with over 500 characters allowed for the search string. Unlike the other CareerCast sites, this one does not provide filtering by job category. You can also enter one zip code or one state and choose a radius centered on that location. Agents: You can save multiple search agents that use all of the search features. Results can be emailed to you as text or HTML with several choices for frequency. The emails list the title, company, city, and state of the first ten job matches with links to the full postings and the rest of the search results. When you click in the email to see the full set of results, it does not remember the number of jobs per page or the time span of the search. Recommendations for you: A good place to post your resume and for searches and alerts. Recommendations for them: Add filtering searches by job category. Add at least a little bit of the job description and the salary (if available) for each job to the agent emails to avoid having to examine each agent result in detail. Have the link in the email for the full search results remember the number of jobs per page and the time span of the search. |
Net-Temps |
| Jobs: Despite the name, this site is not just for temp/contract positions, but for
temporary, temp-to-perm and full time employment through a staffing agency. The site only had about 28,000
job listings on 12/8/05, but claimed over 270,000 resumes and over 5,000 recruiters participating. Resume Quantity: Three. Searchable Resumes: All. Resume Formatting: You can upload a Word resume, build one from a choice of 8 templates, or paste an ASCII resume (up to 15,000 characters). Although they tell you not to, you can use HTML (including CSS blocks or inline style attributes) if you only paste what is between the "BODY" tags. You will probably need to tinker with it. For example, any tables that you use must have their width set to 630 or less. If you leave out the width for any table, everything will display so wide that you have to see it to believe it. Putting <style>table {width:630px;}</style> at the beginning is one way to avoid the problem. There is also an 800 character text "Message to Recruiters" associated with each. Some limited HTML can be used in these, but not tables. Cover Letters: Three. Search Features: Filtering by up to five states or metropolitan area, only one category, and keywords combined with "all" or "any", with "not" (use a "-" before a word) being supported either way. The keywords box holds well over 500 characters. Agents: You can select the email frequency and either text or HTML format. The emails contain the job title, location, duration (if it is a temporary position) and employer, with a link to the full job listing for each position. Recommendations for you: A good place to post your resume and for searches and alerts. Recommendations for them: Fully support HTML resumes. Remove the 15,000 character limit for pasted resumes. Add at least a little bit of the job description and the salary (if available) for each job to the agent emails to avoid having to examine each agent result in detail. |
Operation IT |
| Jobs: Information Technology only. Resume Quantity: Multiple. Searchable Resumes: All. Resume Formatting: Text only. Officially. Unofficially, HTML works. No documented size limit. I was able to paste in all 59k of mine without a problem. For HTML, you can use style attributes, you must only paste what is between the "BODY" tags, and you need to make the whole file into one long line to avoid having extra vertical space that you don't want. They do not provide any these instructions on their site – I had to figure them out the hard way. Search Features: None. This site is for posting resumes only. Recommendations for you: A good place to post your resume. Recommendations for them: Add searches and agents for jobs. |
|
|
| SimplyHired indexes more than 4.5 million jobs
from thousands of sources and provides filtered searches, ratings and other services for job hunters. They
do not publish a list of their sources, so you have to figure out on your own which individual job board agents
you can get rid of once you set up an alert here. SimplyHired has a de-duplication system that shows each
position only once and provides links to all of the sources in which the job was found. They are partnered
with LinkedIn, Google Maps,
PayScale, and others to add value. For example, you can just click
a button to see data about the salaries for that job title in your state and the surrounding areas. A click
on another button brings up a map with the job's location marked. Another button shows you all of the people
in your LinkedIn network that work at the company that is offering the position. Click an icon next to the
company name and you get a brief profile of the employer. Another major feature of SimplyHired is that you can rate a position as "Not Interested", or on a scale of one to five stars. Only you can see the ratings, and rating a job saves the job posting to a "My Jobs" area. You can check a box to filter out the "Not Interested" jobs from that view. Once saved, the site lets you add comments next to the job posting. You can use these comments to track your applications, why you do or don't like the position, or whatever else you like. The comments are also only seen by you. Rating positions also provides another benefit. The site uses them to give you a page of "Suggestions" of other positions that are similar to ones you rated highly, just like your Tivo does for TV shows. Since every job board categorized jobs differently, there is no option to filter jobs based on category, so you may want to think twice about using this instead of the individual job board agents, depending on your particular needs. Advanced searches provide text boxes for "all", "exact phrase", "at least one", "without", "job title", and "company name". You can also filter by distance from a city, state, or zip code and by the age of the posting. There are also filters I haven't seen anywhere else: you can filter by the number of employees or annual revenues of the company and by whether the company is on a particular list, such as the "Fortune 500" or the "Working Mother 100 Best". Searches can be saved as email alerts or as an RSS feed. Emails are sent daily in HTML format and contain the title, company, city, state, originating job board name, posting date and time, and the first bit of the description for the first 20 positions and a link to the full set of matches. They do not save any profile information or resumes. |
Ohio Hiring Management System |
| Jobs with state government. You can store your profile and short (3600 character) ASCII resume. No search agents, but you can sign up to be notified whenever a job in a broad category becomes available. |
tech-centric.net |
| Jobs: Information Technology only. Resume Quantity: None. You can store one profile, which includes your preferred state(s), type(s) of job (direct, contract, etc.), one job function selected from a list, and checkboxes for specific skills, but no resume. Search Features: There are two types of search. 1) You can filter by state(s), type(s) of job (direct, contract, etc.), and using checkboxes for specific skills. 2) You have full Boolean searching for keywords, but no ability to filter by location or type of job. Agents: One. You cannot save a search as an agent. The agent goes strictly by your profile with no support for any type of keyword search. The daily emails are HTML containing the city, state, company, and title of each job with links to the full posting. Recommendations for you: This is not one of my favorites, but I do occasionally see jobs not on other sites. Recommendations for them: Add keyword searches for agents and support filtering down to the metropolitan area level, not just by state. Allow selection of multiple job functions in the profiles. |
WetFeet.com |
| You can set up search agents for jobs. Each agent ANDs keywords, allows only one job category, only one city/state combination (with optional proximity modifier), and no salary criteria. However, you can set up many agents. |
International Relocation Salary Calculator |
| The cost of living data is assembled by the Center for Mobility Resources. The formulas are
based for the most part on those adopted by the Bureau of Labor Statistics. The five major categories for
U.S. and Canadian data are housing costs (33%), utilities (8%), consumables (16%), transportation (10%), and
other services (33%). Outside of North America, we do not include housing cost. In the U.S. and Canada, we have a reliable network of real estate agents supplying us with current housing information. We do not have a comparable network overseas. |
Cost of Living Analysis |
| Tell it your current location, salary, and where you might want to live. It tells you how much money you need to earn in the new location to maintain your current standard of living. |



