CONTENTS

  • Home
  • Columbus in 1863
  • Currency in Columbus
  • An Overview of Civil War Tokens
  • Columbus Storecards
  • Merchant Locations
  • Miscellany
    (A collection of 1863 newspaper articles)
  • Rarity scale
  • Glossary
  • Copyright
  • About the author
  • Annotated bibliography
  • The value of a Civil War Token is whatever a willing buyer and seller agree to. Legitimate dealers may charge more or less than these values. A collector hot on the trail of a missing piece may gladly and wisely pay multiples of these values.

    Civil War Token collecting is unlike any other facet of the hobby. Just about ever token is scarce. And the market for any given piece is razor thin. The scarcity of inventory combined with the paucity of buyers makes for a very inefficient market.

    Experienced collectors generally buy now and ask questions later. The question isn't usually will a better piece come along at a cheaper price, but rather, will another piece ever come along at all.

    These values are for the most common type of each merchant. These values are a moving target based on published guides, sales catalogs and personal observations. Collectors with superior knowledge are invited to email me ( gtebben@usa.com) their own valuations.

    Merchant Catalog
    number
    F/VF XF UNC
    John Grether 200A 30 55 65
    Heintz & Henkle 200B 20 25 50
    J.M. & V. Koerner 200C 15 20 40
    S.T. Martin 200D 20 30 50
    William H. Restieaux 200F 20 25 50
    Henry Schreiner 200G 25 35 50
    Mrs. M.A. Van Houton 200H 100 150 250
    Wagner's Dining Hall 200I 20 25 50
    Wiatt & Bro. 200J 40 75 125